
A Blizzard developer has already answered this question, and the answer is more useful than any tier list:
Josh "Aggrend" Greenfield has said that perfect dungeon play lands very close to optimal questing — at best.
Not faster. Very close, at best, played perfectly. Which means "dungeons or quests" is the wrong question. Neither route wins on its own, and the XP system has been deliberately tuned so that neither can.
The right question is how to combine them, and there the data is unusually clear.
The Answer, Up Front
Quest through each zone, and finish each zone with exactly one run of its dungeon — with every quest for that dungeon already in your log.
That isn't a compromise. It's the single fastest route available, and there's a measurement behind it:
Testers reported close to two levels from one Hall of Thanes or Ruins of Lordaeron run with every quest in the log.
Two levels from one dungeon visit. That's what a first clear with a full quest log is worth — and it's worth almost nothing on the second visit, which is exactly how Blizzard designed it.
Everything below explains why, what changed in the last ten days, and the one rule that will zero your party's XP if you get it wrong.
The Tuning Timeline — and What Dungeon XP Is Worth Now
Dungeon XP has been adjusted four times. If a guide you're reading doesn't mention November, it's out of date.
Date | Change |
|---|
Beta start | Dungeon mob XP cut sharply — Deadmines measured about 75% below Classic |
Oct 1 | Dungeon quest bonus XP cut by 50%. Quests still pay well above normal quests of the same level |
Oct 8 | Dungeon kill XP up ~20% → about 70% below Classic. Party penalty reverted to Classic Era rules, so only your own level matters |
Nov 4 | Launch, shipping with the October tuning |
Nov 8 | Dungeon kill XP up 50% by server-side hotfix |
Nov 13 | Gray-to-any-member zeroed kill XP for the whole party — Blizzard said this "missed the mark" |
Nov 14 | The 12-level rule narrowed that restriction |
What That Arithmetic Adds Up To
The chain is internally consistent, so you can follow it:
25% of Classic (pre-October) × 1.2 (Oct 8) = 30% of Classic 30% × 1.5 (Nov 8) = roughly 45% of Classic
So dungeon trash currently gives somewhere around 45% of its Classic value — a little under half. Both the 45% and the earlier measurements are player arithmetic, not official figures, so treat them as a reasonable estimate rather than a published number.
The direction is what matters: dungeon kill XP has been raised twice in five weeks. Blizzard's stated reasoning for the November buff was to make dungeon runs feel better "to go back in for more runs." They are actively trying to make the trash worth killing.
The 12-Level Rule — Read This Carefully

This is the newest change, the most consequential, and the one most people are about to get wrong.
The rule: kill XP drops to zero for the entire party when a party member is more than 12 levels above the level of the enemies.
A gap of exactly 12 levels still pays XP. 13 or more pays nothing, to anyone.
The check runs per enemy, so your highest-level member usually decides the outcome.
Quest turn-ins are not covered by this rule. Quest XP flows regardless.
Gray mobs still give the killer nothing, which is unchanged Classic behaviour.
The Part Almost Everyone Will Misread
The 12 levels is measured against the enemies, not against your lowest party member.
That distinction matters enormously. Take the Deadmines, with enemies around level 18:
Your highest member | Result |
|---|
Level 30 | 12 above the mobs — XP flows normally |
Level 31 | 13 above the mobs — zero kill XP for the whole party |
A level 31 zeroes the run even if everyone else in the party is level 30. The rule isn't "keep your party close together" — it's "nobody can be more than 12 levels above the mobs."
So before you invite someone, check their level against the dungeon, not against the group.
The Reset Workaround
Instances that were already running when the fix landed keep the old rule. If your kill XP looks wrong, reset the instance. That's the fix, and it's the single most useful practical note in this whole subject.
What This Means for Boosting
A friend can still pull you through a dungeon — they just can't be more than 12 levels above the mobs while doing it. That's a workable window, and it's clearly deliberate: Blizzard narrowed the November 13 version specifically because the stricter rule broke ordinary mixed-level groups.
Quest XP is untouched, so a higher-level friend helping you complete dungeon quests still delivers the majority of the value even if they're outside the 12-level window.
Dungeon Quest XP — Where the Value Actually Lives
The quest bonus was halved on October 1 and dungeon quests still pay more than double their Classic values.
Quest | Classic | Forever (post-Oct 1) |
|---|
VanCleef turn-in (Deadmines) | 2,600 | 6,175 |
Deviate Hides (Wailing Caverns) | 1,600 | 3,100 |
Three core Deadmines quests | 5,400 | 12,825 |
Deadmines full quest set | 8,300 | 18,450 |
All City of Dalaran quests, per faction | (new dungeon) | 15,800 |
(The two Deadmines rows count different quest sets — sources differ on which quests are included, and Forever added a new one worth 2,700 XP.)
One detail worth noting: the VanCleef turn-in peaked at 9,750 XP on beta before the October 1 cut brought it to 6,175 — a 36.6% drop. So the current value is a nerfed figure that is still well over double Classic.
The conclusion is unambiguous: the quests are the dungeon. The trash is a bonus that got buffed twice; the quests are the reason you go.
Why Repeat Runs Don't Pay

Blizzard does not want you grinding dungeons, and three separate mechanics enforce it:
1. Quests are one-time. Your first clear banks the 12,825 or 18,450. Your second clear banks nothing from quests.
2. Trash alone is about 45% of Classic value. The November buff improved repeat runs meaningfully, but a quest-less clear is still the weakest thing you can do with that hour.
3. There's a hard cap of five instance entries per hour. You cannot chain runs even if you wanted to.
So the structure Blizzard built is a dungeon that's worth exactly one visit. Look at how every change points the same way:
Quest bonus halved → you can't farm the quests
Kill XP raised twice → but the run itself isn't a waste
Repeat clears deliberately weak → no grinding
Five entries per hour → no chaining
The 12-level rule → no boosting past the window
That's a coherent design, not a series of accidents. Run each dungeon once, with everything collected, and move on.
The Honest Gap: Nobody Has XP-Per-Hour Figures
Worth stating plainly, because you'll see confident comparisons.
There are no published XP-per-hour figures for either dungeons or questing in Forever. Not from Blizzard, and not from any measurement study. Every ranking you read — including the recommendation in this guide — is reasoning from the rules and from individual quest and mob measurements.
What we do have is solid: the tuning history, the quest values, the 12-level rule, the five-per-hour cap, and a Blizzard developer stating that perfect dungeon play roughly matches optimal questing at best. That's enough to build a route on. It isn't enough to publish a number, and anyone publishing one is inventing it.
Your One-Run-Each Checklist
Twenty-eight dungeons, nine of them new. Run each once, with its quests.
Dungeon | Levels | Location | New |
|---|
Ragefire Chasm | 13–18 | Orgrimmar | |
Hall of Thanes | 13–18 | Under Ironforge, via the Throne Room | ✓ |
Ruins of Lordaeron | 15–20 | Above the Undercity | ✓ |
The Deadmines | 17–20 | Westfall | |
Wailing Caverns | 18–24 | The Barrens | |
Shadowfang Keep | 21–26 | Silverpine Forest | |
Blackfathom Deeps | 23–28 | Ashenvale | |
Excavation Site: Wetlands | 24–29 | Wetlands | ✓ |
The Stockade | 25–29 | Stormwind City | |
City of Dalaran | 28–33 | Alterac Mountains / Dalaran | ✓ |
Gnomeregan | 29–34 | Dun Morogh | |
Razorfen Kraul | 30–38 | Southern Barrens | |
Scarlet Monastery | 30–46 | Tirisfal Glades (four wings) | |
The Drowned City | 35–40 | Off Stranglethorn Vale | ✓ |
Uldaman | 37–45 | Badlands | |
Razorfen Downs | 37–45 | Southern Barrens | |
Zul'Farrak | 40–47 | Tanaris | |
Krol'dok Stronghold | 40–45 | Riverglades | ✓ |
Maraudon | 45–51 | Desolace | |
Alcaz Prison | 48–53 | Dustwallow Marsh | ✓ |
Sunken Temple | 50–55 | Swamp of Sorrows | |
Blackrock Depths | 52–60 | Blackrock Mountain | |
Blackmaw Hold | 55–60 | Azshara | ✓ |
Blackrock Spire | 57–60 | Blackrock Mountain | |
Shaper's Terrace | 58–60 | Un'Goro Crater | ✓ |
Dire Maul | 58–60 | Feralas | |
Stratholme | 58–60 | Eastern Plaguelands | |
Scholomance | 58–60 | Western Plaguelands | |
Scarlet Monastery spans 30–46 across four wings, so it's the one dungeon worth multiple visits — each wing is effectively separate content with its own quests.
And note where the dungeons cluster at the top: five of them are 58–60. Your final two levels have more dungeon options than any other point in the game.
Also worth knowing: three dungeon tier bosses are worth one Legacy Point each — the final boss of the 15–25, 26–45 and 46–60 tiers. Don't skip a tier because you out-levelled it. See our Legacy Points guide.
Check Your Faction Before You Travel

Dungeon value in Forever is almost entirely its quest attachment, and the attachment is wildly uneven by faction.
Dungeon | The Problem |
|---|
Hall of Thanes | No Horde quests at all. Horde get loot and kill XP only, after a trip through Ironforge. Full guide |
Ragefire Chasm | No Alliance quests. Same in reverse, via Ratchet and a corpse run through Orgrimmar. Full guide |
Ruins of Lordaeron | Six Horde quests against four for Alliance — and all four Alliance quests are inside, so nothing can be pre-collected. Full guide |
Razorfen Kraul | Only two quests for Alliance. |
Shadowfang Keep | Reported as "dead" for Alliance. |
Razorfen Downs | Weak for Alliance. |
Upper Scarlet Monastery wings | Weak for Alliance. |
A dungeon with no quests for your faction is worth roughly 45% of Classic trash XP and nothing else. That's the clearest case in the game for skipping content.
When Dungeons Do Beat Questing
Specific situations where the dungeon is the better hour:
You have every quest for it in your log. This is the two-levels-in-one-run case. If you've collected everything — including prerequisites done outside the dungeon — nothing else in that hour competes.
The zone's quests have run dry. The mid-30s to mid-40s was historically the worst drought, though the Riverglades has largely fixed that with 150-plus new quests.
You're in a fast, competent group. Repeat runs are weak but not worthless after the November buff — a group that clears quickly can make a second run acceptable. A slow group cannot.
You want the gear. Dungeon blues sell well and a weapon upgrade speeds up every hour after it. Levelling isn't only about XP per hour.
You're group-levelling anyway. Quest rewards are not split in a group while kill XP is shared — so grouping is strictly better for quest-dense content and dungeons fit naturally into a group's rhythm.
When Questing Wins
Almost everywhere else, and for three structural reasons:
Quest XP is where the buff went. Blizzard cut kill XP across the board — open-world mobs below 30 give 4–20% less than Classic — and put the value into quests. Both your XP and your gold are being pushed the same way: quest rewards from level 48 now pay gold too.
Quest XP ignores the 12-level rule. Turn-ins aren't affected by party composition at all.
Travel and group-forming are real costs. A dungeon run includes assembling four other people, travelling there, and the clear itself. An hour of questing is an hour of questing.
And the shape of the climb favours quests: levels 1–30 are only about 12% of the total XP to 60, and the halfway point is level 48. The back half of your levelling is in zones with dense quest supply and dungeons spread thinly — the 40s and 50s reward questing more than the teens did.
The Route
Quest through the zone, taking everything in the bracket.
Collect every dungeon quest before you form the group — including the ones that start outside. Ragefire Chasm's Hidden Enemies is a five-part chain where four steps happen before you ever enter.
Check faction quest counts. If the dungeon has nothing for your side, skip it.
Check the level spread against the mobs, not against your party. Nobody more than 12 above.
Run it once. Turn in everything.
Move on when mobs turn green. Green quests still pay well; green mobs don't.
Repeat only if your group is genuinely fast.
And log out in an inn — rested XP doubles kill XP, which is now the half of your income that got nerfed, so it's free value where it applies.
FAQ
Is dungeon leveling faster than questing in WoW Forever? No. Josh "Aggrend" Greenfield has said that perfect dungeon play lands very close to optimal questing at best. Dungeon-only grinding is slower than questing. The fastest route is questing plus one run of each dungeon with all its quests collected.
How much XP do dungeon mobs give compared to Classic? Roughly 45% of Classic value after the November 8 buff — derived from player measurements (about 25% of Classic pre-October, +20% on October 8, +50% on November 8). That's player arithmetic, not an official figure.
What is the 12-level rule? Since November 14, kill XP drops to zero for the whole party when a member is more than 12 levels above the enemies. Exactly 12 still pays; 13 or more pays nobody. It's measured against the mobs, not against your party — so a level 31 in the Deadmines zeroes the run even if everyone else is level 30.
My dungeon is giving no kill XP — what do I do? Reset the instance. Instances that were already running when the November 14 fix landed keep the old, stricter rule. Also check that nobody in the party is more than 12 levels above the mobs.
Can a high-level friend still run me through a dungeon? Within the window, yes — they just can't be more than 12 levels above the mobs. Outside it, you get no kill XP, but quest turn-ins are unaffected, so a boost still delivers the dungeon's main value.
Are repeat dungeon runs worth it? Weakly. Your quests pay once, trash is about 45% of Classic, and there's a cap of five instance entries per hour. A fast group can justify a second run; a slow one can't. Blizzard has deliberately built the dungeon to be worth one visit.
How much XP is one dungeon run actually worth? With a full quest log, testers reported close to two levels from one Hall of Thanes or Ruins of Lordaeron run. Deadmines quests total 12,825–18,450 XP depending on which set you count, against 5,400–8,300 in Classic.
Which dungeons should my faction skip? Horde: Hall of Thanes has no Horde quests. Alliance: Ragefire Chasm has none, Razorfen Kraul has two, Shadowfang Keep is dead, and Razorfen Downs plus the upper Scarlet Monastery wings are weak.
Are there XP-per-hour numbers for dungeons versus questing? No published figures exist for either. Any guide quoting a confident XP-per-hour comparison is estimating. The reliable data is the quest values, the tuning history, the 12-level rule and the five-per-hour cap.
Does rested XP help in dungeons? Yes, but only on kills — rested XP doubles kill XP and does nothing for quest turn-ins. Since quest XP is the larger share of a dungeon's value, rested matters less here than it did in Classic.
The Short Version
Neither is faster, and Blizzard said so. Perfect dungeon play roughly matches optimal questing at best.
The fastest route is questing with exactly one run of each dungeon, every quest collected first. Testers got close to two levels from a single Hall of Thanes or Ruins of Lordaeron run with a full log.
Dungeon trash is around 45% of Classic after two buffs. Dungeon quests pay more than double Classic even after being halved in October. The quests are the dungeon.
The new 12-level rule is measured against the mobs, not your party — one member more than 12 levels above the enemies zeroes kill XP for everyone. If your XP looks wrong, reset the instance.
Repeat runs don't pay: quests fire once, trash is weak, and you're capped at five entries per hour. Run each dungeon once and move on.